To restore trust in vaccines, the new leadership at the FDA recently revealed their framework for yearly Covid vaccines. Will their plan restore trust?
The Project 2025 / Heritage Foundation / Thiel-Vance ghouls, with enforcer Russell Vought, want government agencies and trust in them eviscerated. Civil servants and "experts" are the enemies. Bobby and his credentialed, formerly legitimate sidekicks are just the public facing capos, operationalizing destruction and blame, waving hands and stoking anger and divisiveness. The nitty gritty isn't particularly important to the authoritarian cabal in charge, but the gloating, adoring cultists are nice to have.
Meanwhile, Orangefuhrer sends troops to Los Angeles, roils world economy for fun and profit, guts environmental and agricultural regulations, repeatedly ignores court orders, uses pretexts of "antisemitism" and "wokeness" to destroy academia, pushes through massive tax cuts and deficit spending while slashing spending for the less fortunate, mandates make believe peace conferences, and is expected to begin fiddling.
Prasad (hematology) and Makary (oncologic surgery) have the same thing in common as all the covid “contrarian” MDs. They have no relevant expertise on the subject whatsoever.
Atlas - radiology
Ladapo - cardiology
Cole - dermatopath
Bhattacharya - no specialty training at all (???)
Dr Drew - addiction medicine
Dr Oz - CT surgery
I could go on…
We have tens of thousands of specialists with actual expertise on the subject. Thousands of whom served on the front lines during the first wave.
Why do we keep having to listen to this like Prasad/Makary who have no experience or expertise on the subject whatsoever. And, in the case of Prasad, is a whiny little man with an inferiority/Napoleonic complex?
That's like trying to say that because I worked (extensively) in information technology that I'm qualified to talk about programming, or even have a functional understanding of it. I did design, user interface, usability, accessibility, and even advertising and writing. Do I know what programming is? Yep. Am I qualified to make policy concerning it? Nope.
...Says the guy who claims to have expertise in immunology and biological sciences because he happened to look at his jizz under a microscope when he was 12.
Did I not clearly state that I'm not, nor was I, a programmer? I'm not. But part of the technology you're using now, I helped create. (Thousands of us did. Tens of thousands. We built this.)
You are not skilled at forming good arguments or rebuttals.
I was knowledgeable enough to have materials I wrote used in colleges, taught some accredited college myself too.
This is what I learned today by following the trail of the court ruling story he posted, all the way to the site of anti-vaxxer creeps he frequents and posts to: he is not here to educate anyone, change anyone's mind, tell his sad tale of a child harmed with a vaccine injury, blah, blah. blah. He is here with the sole intention of mocking & offending as many people as possible; utilizing bogus charts, posters, and video clips he knows are false and misleading in order to annoy and to purposely provoke an angry reaction from as many people as possible; and if you react, name call and belittle you as if he is somehow intellectually superior to you. He is everything that every creep at the Lioness of Judah website is and then some. You will never win a an argument with him as he only is a poseur of intelligence, and always resorts to a "fall-back" of the basest of name calling foolishness, which he is incapable of rising above. The tip off to his bullshit is a rising sense of anger & annoyance, which is the exact time to avoid buying in. Go to the site I mentioned, and believe me, you will immediately see what I'm taking about. Creeps breed creeps, and he is uncurable.
Certainly not. But it is not my site. And when I saw, for example, others banned, I believed it was a matter of time. I was mistaken. And now I ignore him.
Unfortunately, Ladapo is, or was, well beyond run of the mill - which makes him all the more despicable and dangerous. Check out his Wikipedia entry. He was quite the young clinical academic medicine star. He grew up in a “deeply religious, fundamentalist family," though.
Then, the pandemic happened, and ...
Never trained in cardiology, or a bench researcher. Anubistard continues to exceed his own wrongness.
Any loss of trust happened as a result of misinformation, not information. Misinformation spread by those like Prasad, who has no relevant expertise or experience on the subject whatsoever. While he was making his ignorant podcasts, the rest of us were busy trying to save lives under impossible circumstances.
It is a dangerous time for all in the US. The government is using vaccines as a weapon in the war against established authority, creating a dystopian reality they are using to control the narrative and take power. With the elimination of the ACIP they are again emphasizing that the prior system was doing damage to people and they are fighting evil. The outcome seems uncertain at this time. This is an existential battle that is also a distraction from the existential battle of climate change and nuclear winter. When will they ever learn?
ACIP has not been eliminated! RFK jr fill the committee with Trump-approved vaccine experts. What are the odds that one or more of the following will be a member:
David Geier, James Lyons-Weiler, Brian Hooker, Peter McCullough, Byram Bridle, Russell Blaylock, Paul Thomas, Sherri Tenpenny, Mark Hyman, Christiane Northrup, Andrew Wakefield, Del Bigtree, Joseph Mercola, Bob Sears, Aaron Siri.
He’ll probably throw Bret Weinstein in the mix as well. Not a doctor. No training or experience in medicine whatsoever. No training in immunology or in disease transmission or pathology. But, hey, he has a popular podcast. So that sort of trumps it all, right?
Although I don’t know whether it’s possible for a person who is not a US citizen to be appointed to ACIP or whether such a person can be an unappointed consultant, but I suspect Aseem Malhotra could be added to that list.
To sit on an FDA CDER or CBER Advisory Committee, US residency and legal work authorization are required. Most advisory committee members are US citizens or permanent residents due to security clearance, ethical vetting, and employment authorization concerns. Foreign nationals can serve, but typically only in special circumstances (e.g., rare expertise) and must be approved via internal FDA procedures.
CDC most likely follows the same laws and regulations - or used to - because none of that seems to matter now.
This is the 17th time I have asked you. You did say you'd answer if I answered one of your questions, which I did several days ago. Please answer my question.
Nope - its actually the best time. The next step is to GUT the childhood vaccination schedule. If parents want the vaccines - they can request it. It should no longer be mandatory for school attendance or daycare centers.
People already have choice. What we need to gut is the industry fueling anti-vax rhetoric. Dry up the fearmongering and misinformation, and much of the "hesitancy" will disappear. You have played this silly game long enough; we can only speculate as to why you'd play along.
2. do you support overhauling RCTs and mandating the control arm be a SALINE SOLUTION PLACEBO as the standard ?
3. do you support a vax vs unvax epidemiological study that looks at overall health, allergies, mental development, chronic illnesses, hospital visits to both groups
Your response will tell us how much of a pharma-shill you really are
1. do you support MISINFORMED REJECTION of vaccinations?
2. do you support mandating UNETHICAL RCTs where the control arm is a SALINE SOLUTION as the standard SO THAT NO MORE CLINICAL TRIALS WILL EVER BE DONE because they are UNETHICAL?
3. do you support a vaccinated vs unvaccinated epidemiological study HOUNDED BY CONFOUNDING VARIABLES that looks at questions long ago settled by ACTUAL RESEARCH SCIENTISTS.
His list tells us how much of a child killer this fv<king arsehole really is.
This is frightening stuff. And Orwellian. Thus right wing voices spread the seeds of distrust of vaccines and then they say their actions are taken because many distrust vaccines.
While you're thinking for a clever answer, repeat after me:
PERSONAL ANECDOTES ARE NOT EVIDENCE.
And they sure as hell do not negate the post marketing surveillance of millions of vaccinations objectively measured and with confounders accounted for.
CONvid pushed it over the edge. It was "ok" while you had mandates for childhood vaccination for school attendance - that didnt wake up ignorant parents. But the moment you pushed mandates that affected jobs and living quarters - a lot of people WOKE UP
Brilliant! It's extraordinary that these two qualified doctors are spouting such unscientific rubbish. They are bringing the medical profession into disrepute.
"So, what are Makary and Prasad really talking about? Both men serve at the behest of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., an anti-vaccine activist who is interested in making vaccines less available, less affordable, and more feared."
100% BULLSHIT.
They want to ensure their safety to the greatest extent possible because people were promised one thing, took the Covid vaccine, it didn't work as well as promised and there were many more side effects they experiened than expected.
"Both men share RFK Jr.’s conspiratorial beliefs that the federal government lied about vaccine safety issues"
The government lied repeatedly even after information was coming out of Israel about heart issues for young men and other side effects very early in the vaccination period. There were also non Covid related excess deaths were rising and NEVER explained I had a blood pressure spike, tinnitus, and easy bruising, but fortunatly it all subsided in a few months.
" wrongly promoted the vaccine for people who didn’t need it, and behaved in a manner bordering on corruption. "
They did!
From what I gather, even you did not take one of the boosters because you are healthy. There were FDA officeals that resigned rather than approve them for certain groups.
I'm not sure who is controlling you at this point, but I can't but conclude anything other than you are terrible human being because I know you are not misguided or uninformed.
No one is controlling Offit. He has spent his whole career in virology and vaccine development. Offit is one of the few who has expert knowledge about vaccines and safety he is who we should be listening to and taking guidance from.
That's really going to help convince people of your position.
It's 100% certain the govt promised the vaccine would prevent transmission and infection even though they knew that was a lie from the start. They said it was very safe even though young healthy men (low risk from Covid) were having heart issues and people like me were having significant non life threatening issues. The risks from Covid among healthy young people were very low, the potential risks of the vaccine are still unfolding in various studies on the immune system and no one has still explained all the non Covid related excess deaths. They just wrote them all off as correlation does not equal causation. That's the BULLSHIT!
It's 100% certain the govt promised the vaccine would prevent transmission and infection." Not quite, but it is certain that your rigid, authoritarian thinking renders you incapable of comprehending that which is not black or white.
It's 100% certain that you're a toxic, dimwitted magatard.
What's sad is you are so scientifically illiterate and unable to think critically to have believed all the conspiracies spouted by those who are happy to have you die unvaccinated from covid. You're sad and that is sad.
Israel flagged the myocarditis issue in April 2021.
The CDC acknowledged their data and then did their own analysis. A CDC presentation in May highlighted the issue, and safety alerts were issued in June IIRC.
Tell us…when exactly did the CDC lie about myocarditis?
I want to be appointed to this committee as well. Although I never even went to med school, I immunized myself by going barefoot into an airplane toilet and swimming in sewage infested waters. Does that not qualify me?
"COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis has a mild initial clinical course but myocardial injury as evidenced by LGE on CMR at initial presentation is common"
Lancet published that C-VAM is common. Good job, VCIP! How many mRNA injections would be moved if the buying public are informed that C-VAM is "common?"
You are equally dishonest as Peter McCullough, on whose site I left a similar message contesting that he did not address the fact that you are more likely to develop myocarditis directly from SARS-CoV-2 disease than you are from any Covid-19 vaccine, for example:
Haryalchi, K., et al. The importance of myocarditis in Covid-19. Health Sci Rep. 2022 Jan 13;5(1):e488. doi: 10.1002/hsr2.488.
Bavashi, C., et al. Special Article - Acute myocardial injury in patients hospitalized with COVID-19 infection: A review. Prog Cardiovasc Dis . 2020 Sep-Oct;63(5):682-689. doi: 10.1016/j. pcad.2020.05.013
And in a very recent study, the financial burden to the healthcare system for readmissions for myocarditis derived directly from SARS-CoV-02 are staggering:
Kommineni, DF., et al. Risk Factors, Trends, and Financial Impact for 30-Day Unplanned Readmissions in Patients Admitted With Myocarditis and COVID-19: Insights From the Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project (HCUP) Nationwide Readmission Database. Cureus. 2025 Mar 10;17(3):e80371. doi: 10.7759/cureus.80371
Nevertheless, a traditional view is repeated many times, but summarized well here:
Sousa, JP, et al. Anti-SARS-CoV-2 vaccine-induced myocarditis - real but, in general, rare and mild: A consensus statement from the Studies Committee of the Portuguese Society of Cardiology,Rev Port Cardiol. 2023 Feb;42(2):161-167 doi: 10.1016/j.repc.2023.01.003.
ignorant of what the myocarditis was like--often with zero symptoms, and only detected by a blood test because recipients were on a clinical trial!! Myocarditis occurs about 7-times as often and is more severe after virus infection!! Stop lying....
It's not "common." He's confusing myocardial injury being "common" in cases of C-VAM with C-VAM itself being "common." I doubt he read the actual paper TBH.
You are correct, I did misinterpret the finding of the Lancet paper I cited. Thank you for the catch:
"Myocardial injury as evidenced by LGE on CMR imaging is common in patients with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination who present to the hospital, especially in adolescent males."
Ah, I was wrong, you are not a legend in your own mind. My apologies. You are just one of these irritating fools who insists on spewing out misinformation that kills.
"...myocardial injury as evidenced by LGE on CMR at initial presentation is common." No shit, Sherlock. If you're presenting to the ER with a (*rare*) case of C-VAM, of course myocardial injury as evidenced by LGE on CMR at initial presentation will be "common." Myocarditis = myocardial injury. No surprise there. That does NOT, however, mean that C-VAM itself is "common."
The new guidelines once again show how the Trump administration puts politics over science. A retrospective study found that
“ We found that pregnant individuals who had COVID-19 in early or midpregnancy had a nearly 2-fold increased risk of stillbirth compared with pregnant individuals with no infection.”
Cassidy got assurances from that pathological liar, RFK junior, that he would not interfere with the ACIP.
The pathological liar then fired the entire 17 members of the ACIP.
Cassidy then got assurances that the pathological liar would not put any anti-vaccine advocates on the new ACIP panel.
The pathological liar then nominated three anti-vaccine advocates for the panel: Vicky Pebsworth Debold, board member and volunteer director for the antivax National Vaccine (Mis)Information Center, Martin Kulldorff, co-author of the Great Barrington Declaration, and Robert Malone.
Will Cassidy's next move be to extract an assurance from that pathological liar that the anti-vaccine advocates he chose will put aside their conflicts-of-interest as anti-vaccine advocates when voting as members of the ACIP?
Of course, it is possible that Cassidy is just a disgusting politician and will look for any justification for his egregious act of casting the deciding vote to have that pathological liar as secretary of the HHS.
Your last paragraph accounts for most of it, I think. He's a piece of shit that feigned some skepticism and concern - Relying on the gullibility of some magoids.
It is so despicable that uninformed, uneducated and/or corrupt appointees are making recommendations about vaccines that save lives and prevent long term damage FROM illness that is totally unnecessary. That a dangerous felon appointed these rabble rousers to preach the orange gospel and we are forced to suffer at their hands. It is a dangerous time to be a child or a woman with these *%# in control. But then again, only old white men with fortunes have any value in this society
"A study of more than 100 million people found that the vaccine is remarkably safe."
V-SAFE data reveals 7.7% of mRNA injections recipients sought medical care for adverse events after the injections.
BMJ published SAEs happen in 1/800 mRNA injection recipients.
"Safe" apparently is in the eye of the beholder.
"Covid vaccines remained effective in preventing Covid in all age groups,"- perhaps- but the promise was that the injections would prevent infections- "stop the spread"- yet injected persons were advised to wear up three masks.
Makary and Prassad are referred to as: "two sycophants from the FDA."
Offit is now peddling conspiracy theory drivel that FDA officials are involved in plots and schemes to harm children.
I believe that this post by Offit makes it indisputable. He has officially lost his shit. His writings are now rife with signals of clinical depression and paranoia. He reminds me of Captain Queeg rolling his balls on the bridge of the USS Caine while the hurricane rages.
I can't wait for his next screed- when he pontificates and rages about getting summarily kicked off the ACIP. Pass the popcorn!
You're a decade-long anti-vaccine crusader. You fabricated "religious beliefs," teamed up with the most malignant opportunists, and exploited your own daughter for your twisted mission.
How were the pay and the perks, as Maryland lead for Kennedy narcissistic presidential campaign? Still on "Children's Health Defense" payroll?
Worse than just another nutjob. He's an actual player in vaccine-demonization-world, for years. Search the name, in quotations. Whoring his family and religion for the major demons.
What I clearly remember was waiting for Fauci and Welensky to say that getting and recovering from Covid does give immunity. But they brushed it off and would only talk about vaccine immunity. I would search constantly and find other countries reporting benefits of natural immunity. Maybe they would write about it in the journals somewhere but in front of cameras and in news print it was not mentioned or at best buried in the article. Or even if it was mentioned by someone else, other doctors and researchers, they always said that hybrid (natural and vaccine immunity) was better. Having sons in the age range where myocarditis was a risk and past immunity from infection was present and the benefit was very low and that this was a new product (conceding mRNA had been studied for some time) I have to say I have lost trust in the past scientific community. I appreciate Dr Offits’s contributions to the discussion but I also have to say that change is definitely needed and Dr Bhattacharya and Dr Prasad have been scrutinized by the media as a whole much more than the past administration’s appointees for trying to bring that change.
The Project 2025 / Heritage Foundation / Thiel-Vance ghouls, with enforcer Russell Vought, want government agencies and trust in them eviscerated. Civil servants and "experts" are the enemies. Bobby and his credentialed, formerly legitimate sidekicks are just the public facing capos, operationalizing destruction and blame, waving hands and stoking anger and divisiveness. The nitty gritty isn't particularly important to the authoritarian cabal in charge, but the gloating, adoring cultists are nice to have.
Meanwhile, Orangefuhrer sends troops to Los Angeles, roils world economy for fun and profit, guts environmental and agricultural regulations, repeatedly ignores court orders, uses pretexts of "antisemitism" and "wokeness" to destroy academia, pushes through massive tax cuts and deficit spending while slashing spending for the less fortunate, mandates make believe peace conferences, and is expected to begin fiddling.
Prasad (hematology) and Makary (oncologic surgery) have the same thing in common as all the covid “contrarian” MDs. They have no relevant expertise on the subject whatsoever.
Atlas - radiology
Ladapo - cardiology
Cole - dermatopath
Bhattacharya - no specialty training at all (???)
Dr Drew - addiction medicine
Dr Oz - CT surgery
I could go on…
We have tens of thousands of specialists with actual expertise on the subject. Thousands of whom served on the front lines during the first wave.
Why do we keep having to listen to this like Prasad/Makary who have no experience or expertise on the subject whatsoever. And, in the case of Prasad, is a whiny little man with an inferiority/Napoleonic complex?
"Dr Drew"
I'd forgotten all about Dr. Andrew Pinsky.
Not sure why he contracted his name. |:
>Ladapo - cardiology
Myo/Peri Carditis have entered the chat
That's like trying to say that because I worked (extensively) in information technology that I'm qualified to talk about programming, or even have a functional understanding of it. I did design, user interface, usability, accessibility, and even advertising and writing. Do I know what programming is? Yep. Am I qualified to make policy concerning it? Nope.
>That's like trying to say that because I worked (extensively) in information technology that I'm qualified to talk about programming
If you are not qualified to talk about programming then you NEVER did anything remotely approaching software engineering.
Your pathetic attempt to draw an analogy made zero sense - likely because YOU HAVE NO EXPERIENCE in the field of software development
...Says the guy who claims to have expertise in immunology and biological sciences because he happened to look at his jizz under a microscope when he was 12.
Say, Anubis...Do viruses exist?
[18th time of asking]
Anubis: "Your pathetic attempt to draw an analogy made zero sense".
Not to a science illiterate crank who has the hots for Malhotra's bollocks and anal discharge.
Did I not clearly state that I'm not, nor was I, a programmer? I'm not. But part of the technology you're using now, I helped create. (Thousands of us did. Tens of thousands. We built this.)
You are not skilled at forming good arguments or rebuttals.
I was knowledgeable enough to have materials I wrote used in colleges, taught some accredited college myself too.
Anubis: "Ladapo - cardiology ... Myo/Peri Carditis have entered the chat"
This sad little boy thinks a cardiologist is a research scientist.
He is just a run-of-the-mill fake expert.
This is what I learned today by following the trail of the court ruling story he posted, all the way to the site of anti-vaxxer creeps he frequents and posts to: he is not here to educate anyone, change anyone's mind, tell his sad tale of a child harmed with a vaccine injury, blah, blah. blah. He is here with the sole intention of mocking & offending as many people as possible; utilizing bogus charts, posters, and video clips he knows are false and misleading in order to annoy and to purposely provoke an angry reaction from as many people as possible; and if you react, name call and belittle you as if he is somehow intellectually superior to you. He is everything that every creep at the Lioness of Judah website is and then some. You will never win a an argument with him as he only is a poseur of intelligence, and always resorts to a "fall-back" of the basest of name calling foolishness, which he is incapable of rising above. The tip off to his bullshit is a rising sense of anger & annoyance, which is the exact time to avoid buying in. Go to the site I mentioned, and believe me, you will immediately see what I'm taking about. Creeps breed creeps, and he is uncurable.
Certainly not. But it is not my site. And when I saw, for example, others banned, I believed it was a matter of time. I was mistaken. And now I ignore him.
Unfortunately, Ladapo is, or was, well beyond run of the mill - which makes him all the more despicable and dangerous. Check out his Wikipedia entry. He was quite the young clinical academic medicine star. He grew up in a “deeply religious, fundamentalist family," though.
Then, the pandemic happened, and ...
Never trained in cardiology, or a bench researcher. Anubistard continues to exceed his own wrongness.
Only in the sense of saying you need a pilot on your town planning sanitation committee because sometimes a plane flies nearby.
Any loss of trust happened as a result of misinformation, not information. Misinformation spread by those like Prasad, who has no relevant expertise or experience on the subject whatsoever. While he was making his ignorant podcasts, the rest of us were busy trying to save lives under impossible circumstances.
It is a dangerous time for all in the US. The government is using vaccines as a weapon in the war against established authority, creating a dystopian reality they are using to control the narrative and take power. With the elimination of the ACIP they are again emphasizing that the prior system was doing damage to people and they are fighting evil. The outcome seems uncertain at this time. This is an existential battle that is also a distraction from the existential battle of climate change and nuclear winter. When will they ever learn?
ACIP has not been eliminated! RFK jr fill the committee with Trump-approved vaccine experts. What are the odds that one or more of the following will be a member:
David Geier, James Lyons-Weiler, Brian Hooker, Peter McCullough, Byram Bridle, Russell Blaylock, Paul Thomas, Sherri Tenpenny, Mark Hyman, Christiane Northrup, Andrew Wakefield, Del Bigtree, Joseph Mercola, Bob Sears, Aaron Siri.
He’ll probably throw Bret Weinstein in the mix as well. Not a doctor. No training or experience in medicine whatsoever. No training in immunology or in disease transmission or pathology. But, hey, he has a popular podcast. So that sort of trumps it all, right?
Although I don’t know whether it’s possible for a person who is not a US citizen to be appointed to ACIP or whether such a person can be an unappointed consultant, but I suspect Aseem Malhotra could be added to that list.
To sit on an FDA CDER or CBER Advisory Committee, US residency and legal work authorization are required. Most advisory committee members are US citizens or permanent residents due to security clearance, ethical vetting, and employment authorization concerns. Foreign nationals can serve, but typically only in special circumstances (e.g., rare expertise) and must be approved via internal FDA procedures.
CDC most likely follows the same laws and regulations - or used to - because none of that seems to matter now.
By "Trump's Experts" you mean dumbshit antivax child killers, yes?
HERES HOPING !!!
Anubis <-- Assem Malhotra's arse kissing fanboy.
And I mean "BOY"!
Suck in his bollocks and the shit that flows out of his arse
All you British and Australian pharma-shills that Offit stocks his comments section with; are laughable
Clearly couldn't find an American stupid enough to shill at that level so bring in the Brits and their SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP under our desk
Do viruses exist, Anubis?
This is the 17th time I have asked you. You did say you'd answer if I answered one of your questions, which I did several days ago. Please answer my question.
"All you British and Australian pharma-shills"
Antivax Anubis is so stupid that he does not even realise that Aseem Malhotra is British.
Too funny!
And there is that brain-dead antivax trope "pharma-shill".
Meanwhile RFK junior is raking in millions every year from legal action against the manufacturers of vaccines.
THAT is the massive CONFLICT OF INTEREST!
ACIP's gone, to be replaced by anti-vax cronies of Kennedy.
All vaccines are on the firing line now. Worst time ever in recent history to be an infant or child in the US.
Thanks for your comments here and elsewhere. Do you think that VICP is in danger?
Nope - its actually the best time. The next step is to GUT the childhood vaccination schedule. If parents want the vaccines - they can request it. It should no longer be mandatory for school attendance or daycare centers.
We have played this silly game long enough
Anubis <-- "We have played this silly [boy] long enough.
It's like kicking a dead horse.
The stupidest antivaxxer of all, he is an unpaid tool of the anti-vaccine echo machine groomed by that ridiculous crank, rombios.
People already have choice. What we need to gut is the industry fueling anti-vax rhetoric. Dry up the fearmongering and misinformation, and much of the "hesitancy" will disappear. You have played this silly game long enough; we can only speculate as to why you'd play along.
Lets test your theory
1. do you support INFORMED CONSENT ?
2. do you support overhauling RCTs and mandating the control arm be a SALINE SOLUTION PLACEBO as the standard ?
3. do you support a vax vs unvax epidemiological study that looks at overall health, allergies, mental development, chronic illnesses, hospital visits to both groups
Your response will tell us how much of a pharma-shill you really are
This is what this fv<king arsehole really means:
1. do you support MISINFORMED REJECTION of vaccinations?
2. do you support mandating UNETHICAL RCTs where the control arm is a SALINE SOLUTION as the standard SO THAT NO MORE CLINICAL TRIALS WILL EVER BE DONE because they are UNETHICAL?
3. do you support a vaccinated vs unvaccinated epidemiological study HOUNDED BY CONFOUNDING VARIABLES that looks at questions long ago settled by ACTUAL RESEARCH SCIENTISTS.
His list tells us how much of a child killer this fv<king arsehole really is.
First, if you're going to use the word theory, use it correctly.
Whatever alternate reality it is you live in, the lizard people do not, in fact, deliver shill-buks in burlap bags to me every month.
(Mmm shill-buks)
If it looks like I'm not taking your questions seriously, it's because they aren't serious questions, and you know it.
As always great points! Thank you Dr Offit for your voice on vaccines!
You can get off your knees now. Youve been there long enough
Anubis <-- "on your knees now".
Aseem Malhotra has come looking for his unpaid bottom feeder.
This is frightening stuff. And Orwellian. Thus right wing voices spread the seeds of distrust of vaccines and then they say their actions are taken because many distrust vaccines.
People already distrusted vaccines due to personal experiences. It was more left-wing than right wing decades ago.
What does the C stand for Bethy?
While you're thinking for a clever answer, repeat after me:
PERSONAL ANECDOTES ARE NOT EVIDENCE.
And they sure as hell do not negate the post marketing surveillance of millions of vaccinations objectively measured and with confounders accounted for.
CONvid pushed it over the edge. It was "ok" while you had mandates for childhood vaccination for school attendance - that didnt wake up ignorant parents. But the moment you pushed mandates that affected jobs and living quarters - a lot of people WOKE UP
Anubis <-- "ignorant parent"
Every accusation is an accusation.
He was gaslit by Rambling Rombo into believing he killed his son's brain and now Rombo lives in HIS brain for free.
Spot on.
RFKjr right wing? SINCE WHEN?
clown world
Brilliant! It's extraordinary that these two qualified doctors are spouting such unscientific rubbish. They are bringing the medical profession into disrepute.
Indeed , disheartening for us Who’ve seen vaccines make some diseases virtually extinct .
https://vaclib.org/sites/debate/web1.html
its your ability to think rationally thats extinct
Oh, and here is the Nubes lying graphs.
Of course, he has no idea how to read a graph which is why it was so easy for Rambling Rombo to fool the little thing.
"So, what are Makary and Prasad really talking about? Both men serve at the behest of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., an anti-vaccine activist who is interested in making vaccines less available, less affordable, and more feared."
100% BULLSHIT.
They want to ensure their safety to the greatest extent possible because people were promised one thing, took the Covid vaccine, it didn't work as well as promised and there were many more side effects they experiened than expected.
"Both men share RFK Jr.’s conspiratorial beliefs that the federal government lied about vaccine safety issues"
The government lied repeatedly even after information was coming out of Israel about heart issues for young men and other side effects very early in the vaccination period. There were also non Covid related excess deaths were rising and NEVER explained I had a blood pressure spike, tinnitus, and easy bruising, but fortunatly it all subsided in a few months.
" wrongly promoted the vaccine for people who didn’t need it, and behaved in a manner bordering on corruption. "
They did!
From what I gather, even you did not take one of the boosters because you are healthy. There were FDA officeals that resigned rather than approve them for certain groups.
I'm not sure who is controlling you at this point, but I can't but conclude anything other than you are terrible human being because I know you are not misguided or uninformed.
No one is controlling Offit. He has spent his whole career in virology and vaccine development. Offit is one of the few who has expert knowledge about vaccines and safety he is who we should be listening to and taking guidance from.
You just sound like a whiny science denier.
>No one is controlling Offit.
You best believe his MERCK appointed chair - says otherwise. Also his rotavirus vaccine on the childhood vaccination schedule doubles it
Do viruses exist?
Can you answer...I've asked you 19 times now.
WC is a Malone, Siri, Kirsch, etc. sucker.
Your mother was always the most enjoyable babysitter.
That's really going to help convince people of your position.
It's 100% certain the govt promised the vaccine would prevent transmission and infection even though they knew that was a lie from the start. They said it was very safe even though young healthy men (low risk from Covid) were having heart issues and people like me were having significant non life threatening issues. The risks from Covid among healthy young people were very low, the potential risks of the vaccine are still unfolding in various studies on the immune system and no one has still explained all the non Covid related excess deaths. They just wrote them all off as correlation does not equal causation. That's the BULLSHIT!
It's 100% certain the govt promised the vaccine would prevent transmission and infection." Not quite, but it is certain that your rigid, authoritarian thinking renders you incapable of comprehending that which is not black or white.
It's 100% certain that you're a toxic, dimwitted magatard.
https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F99b63013-8b6f-457e-aa9f-9ee72f134c88_1230x1216.jpeg
What's sad is you are so scientifically illiterate and unable to think critically to have believed all the conspiracies spouted by those who are happy to have you die unvaccinated from covid. You're sad and that is sad.
Wow a flu derivative with a 99.7% recovery rate. Yeah real scary stuff
Anubis <-- "really scary"
Kills infants and children and laughs his head off while doing it.
All because an antivax cretin told him he killed his child's brain by vaccinating him.
There is no sadder loser than that
"Flu derivative"....you mean viruses DO exist?
Then why can't you just say so?
Water Closet (aka "the toilet) <-- "100% certain..."
...that the toilet is telling lies.
Regurgitating all the shit that has flowed into its bowl.
>It's 100% certain the govt promised the vaccine would prevent transmission and infection even though they knew that was a lie from the start.
I got you fam. Here you go.
https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F99b63013-8b6f-457e-aa9f-9ee72f134c88_1230x1216.jpeg
Anubis: "here you go" [the silly thing links to his favourite poster}
Yeah, it's Nubes again lying with a link to a lying poster of lying quotes, most of whom are not even scientists.
Yeah, that's how stupid this boy is!
Water Closet (aka "The toilet) <-- "terrible human being"
The Toilet is clueless.
And every accusation is an admission.
And the anti-vaccine echo machine has stolen his brain.
Israel flagged the myocarditis issue in April 2021.
The CDC acknowledged their data and then did their own analysis. A CDC presentation in May highlighted the issue, and safety alerts were issued in June IIRC.
Tell us…when exactly did the CDC lie about myocarditis?
Details and links please…
I want to be appointed to this committee as well. Although I never even went to med school, I immunized myself by going barefoot into an airplane toilet and swimming in sewage infested waters. Does that not qualify me?
Thanks for pointing out the fact that mRNA vaccine myocarditis has essentially vanished as an issue.
It pretty much affected only younger males who received the 2nd dose of the 2-dose primary course within 3-4 weeks of the first shot.
This is no longer policy or practice; the 2nd shot is given at 3 months, and myocarditis is not happening.
"COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis has a mild initial clinical course but myocardial injury as evidenced by LGE on CMR at initial presentation is common"
Lancet published that C-VAM is common. Good job, VCIP! How many mRNA injections would be moved if the buying public are informed that C-VAM is "common?"
Good riddance, and thank you Secretary Kennedy.
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5370(24)00388-2/fulltext
You are equally dishonest as Peter McCullough, on whose site I left a similar message contesting that he did not address the fact that you are more likely to develop myocarditis directly from SARS-CoV-2 disease than you are from any Covid-19 vaccine, for example:
Haryalchi, K., et al. The importance of myocarditis in Covid-19. Health Sci Rep. 2022 Jan 13;5(1):e488. doi: 10.1002/hsr2.488.
Bavashi, C., et al. Special Article - Acute myocardial injury in patients hospitalized with COVID-19 infection: A review. Prog Cardiovasc Dis . 2020 Sep-Oct;63(5):682-689. doi: 10.1016/j. pcad.2020.05.013
And in a very recent study, the financial burden to the healthcare system for readmissions for myocarditis derived directly from SARS-CoV-02 are staggering:
Kommineni, DF., et al. Risk Factors, Trends, and Financial Impact for 30-Day Unplanned Readmissions in Patients Admitted With Myocarditis and COVID-19: Insights From the Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project (HCUP) Nationwide Readmission Database. Cureus. 2025 Mar 10;17(3):e80371. doi: 10.7759/cureus.80371
Nevertheless, a traditional view is repeated many times, but summarized well here:
Sousa, JP, et al. Anti-SARS-CoV-2 vaccine-induced myocarditis - real but, in general, rare and mild: A consensus statement from the Studies Committee of the Portuguese Society of Cardiology,Rev Port Cardiol. 2023 Feb;42(2):161-167 doi: 10.1016/j.repc.2023.01.003.
Good riddance to you, son.
ignorant of what the myocarditis was like--often with zero symptoms, and only detected by a blood test because recipients were on a clinical trial!! Myocarditis occurs about 7-times as often and is more severe after virus infection!! Stop lying....
>”Lancet published that Covid vaccine associated myocarditis is common”
BS.
…Where?
What is the incidence rate reported in that article?
It's not "common." He's confusing myocardial injury being "common" in cases of C-VAM with C-VAM itself being "common." I doubt he read the actual paper TBH.
You are correct, I did misinterpret the finding of the Lancet paper I cited. Thank you for the catch:
"Myocardial injury as evidenced by LGE on CMR imaging is common in patients with myocarditis after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination who present to the hospital, especially in adolescent males."
The incidence of vaccine myocarditis in young men is around 40/100,000, up from around 10/100,000 baseline.
Not common, but rather rare.
Also mild, and usually inconsequential.
So inconsequential Edward Dowd wrote on book on "Sudden Adult Death Syndrome"
Joshua Amazing.
Ah, I was wrong, you are not a legend in your own mind. My apologies. You are just one of these irritating fools who insists on spewing out misinformation that kills.
Before you comment again...
LEARN SOME SCIENCE!
"...myocardial injury as evidenced by LGE on CMR at initial presentation is common." No shit, Sherlock. If you're presenting to the ER with a (*rare*) case of C-VAM, of course myocardial injury as evidenced by LGE on CMR at initial presentation will be "common." Myocarditis = myocardial injury. No surprise there. That does NOT, however, mean that C-VAM itself is "common."
Your daughter hates you, Josh. Her actual friends know. She pretends otherwise at times, to get what she wants. You've taught her that.
What a moronic statement.
Hardly. Search the name. See what he dragged her through and deprived her of, for his crusade, while employed by Kennedy's operations.
He's Anne Arundel County infamous, and my and my neighbor's teenagers have acquaintances in common with Josh's in-family victims.
https://www.thebaltimorebanner.com/politics-power/national-politics/rfk-jr-president-maryland-kathleen-kennedy-townsend-C4T4ZEW73FCO7KSLT4PHNSUFSA/
Ode to Saint Bobby Kennedy in Baltimore Sun;
https://www.baltimoresun.com/2025/01/08/backlash-against-rfk-jr-is-misdirected-guest-commentary/
Propagating distortions and lies, well before COVID;
https://www.eyeonannapolis.net/2019/11/opinion-hpv-vaccine-incentive-payments-need-to-stop/
Amazing Josh ... a legend in his own mind.
Training in critical thinking: ZERO!
People are common but the vast majority are harmless.
The new guidelines once again show how the Trump administration puts politics over science. A retrospective study found that
“ We found that pregnant individuals who had COVID-19 in early or midpregnancy had a nearly 2-fold increased risk of stillbirth compared with pregnant individuals with no infection.”
(https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9970919/#:~:text=DOD%20was%208.7%25.-,We%20identified%202342%20(1.3%25)%20pregnancies%20with%20COVID%2D19%20in,with%20and%20without%20COVID%2D19.)
To withdraw recommendations for pregnant folks will likely mean an increase in stillbirths.
If the CDC does not recommend a vaccine, often times insurers will not pay for them. This will- as always - affect the disadvantaged most.
Senator Cassidy is a gullible fool.
Cassidy got assurances from that pathological liar, RFK junior, that he would not interfere with the ACIP.
The pathological liar then fired the entire 17 members of the ACIP.
Cassidy then got assurances that the pathological liar would not put any anti-vaccine advocates on the new ACIP panel.
The pathological liar then nominated three anti-vaccine advocates for the panel: Vicky Pebsworth Debold, board member and volunteer director for the antivax National Vaccine (Mis)Information Center, Martin Kulldorff, co-author of the Great Barrington Declaration, and Robert Malone.
Will Cassidy's next move be to extract an assurance from that pathological liar that the anti-vaccine advocates he chose will put aside their conflicts-of-interest as anti-vaccine advocates when voting as members of the ACIP?
Of course, it is possible that Cassidy is just a disgusting politician and will look for any justification for his egregious act of casting the deciding vote to have that pathological liar as secretary of the HHS.
Your last paragraph accounts for most of it, I think. He's a piece of shit that feigned some skepticism and concern - Relying on the gullibility of some magoids.
It is so despicable that uninformed, uneducated and/or corrupt appointees are making recommendations about vaccines that save lives and prevent long term damage FROM illness that is totally unnecessary. That a dangerous felon appointed these rabble rousers to preach the orange gospel and we are forced to suffer at their hands. It is a dangerous time to be a child or a woman with these *%# in control. But then again, only old white men with fortunes have any value in this society
http://www.vaclib.org/sites/debate/web1.html
That says polio is an infectious disease.
....But you claim viruses do not exist.
So are they wrong?
"A study of more than 100 million people found that the vaccine is remarkably safe."
V-SAFE data reveals 7.7% of mRNA injections recipients sought medical care for adverse events after the injections.
BMJ published SAEs happen in 1/800 mRNA injection recipients.
"Safe" apparently is in the eye of the beholder.
"Covid vaccines remained effective in preventing Covid in all age groups,"- perhaps- but the promise was that the injections would prevent infections- "stop the spread"- yet injected persons were advised to wear up three masks.
Makary and Prassad are referred to as: "two sycophants from the FDA."
Offit is now peddling conspiracy theory drivel that FDA officials are involved in plots and schemes to harm children.
I believe that this post by Offit makes it indisputable. He has officially lost his shit. His writings are now rife with signals of clinical depression and paranoia. He reminds me of Captain Queeg rolling his balls on the bridge of the USS Caine while the hurricane rages.
I can't wait for his next screed- when he pontificates and rages about getting summarily kicked off the ACIP. Pass the popcorn!
You're a decade-long anti-vaccine crusader. You fabricated "religious beliefs," teamed up with the most malignant opportunists, and exploited your own daughter for your twisted mission.
How were the pay and the perks, as Maryland lead for Kennedy narcissistic presidential campaign? Still on "Children's Health Defense" payroll?
your screed is full of patent nonsense. You are not to be taken seriously......
Worse than just another nutjob. He's an actual player in vaccine-demonization-world, for years. Search the name, in quotations. Whoring his family and religion for the major demons.
He’s not on the ACIP, as far as I am aware.
I think the guy who has “lost his shit” is you.
Makary and Prasad have flip flopped more than a stranded sardine on Covid and vaccines.
The VSafe data was a record of how many individuals sought a medical opinion/advice in a year following a vaccine. It was, as you say, 7.7%
Since the usual background rate of medical consultation in a year is twice that, the conclusion must be that vaccines make people healthier.
…Let’s MAHA that one all the way to its logical conclusion, shall we?
you may be correct- Offit is certainly a past member of ACIP- thank you for the correction!
>"Safe" apparently is in the eye of the beholder
So safe you need liability shielding
You can’t sue Pfizer or Moderna if you have severe Covid vaccine side effects. The government likely won’t compensate you for damages either
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/16/covid-vaccine-side-effects-compensation-lawsuit.html
What I clearly remember was waiting for Fauci and Welensky to say that getting and recovering from Covid does give immunity. But they brushed it off and would only talk about vaccine immunity. I would search constantly and find other countries reporting benefits of natural immunity. Maybe they would write about it in the journals somewhere but in front of cameras and in news print it was not mentioned or at best buried in the article. Or even if it was mentioned by someone else, other doctors and researchers, they always said that hybrid (natural and vaccine immunity) was better. Having sons in the age range where myocarditis was a risk and past immunity from infection was present and the benefit was very low and that this was a new product (conceding mRNA had been studied for some time) I have to say I have lost trust in the past scientific community. I appreciate Dr Offits’s contributions to the discussion but I also have to say that change is definitely needed and Dr Bhattacharya and Dr Prasad have been scrutinized by the media as a whole much more than the past administration’s appointees for trying to bring that change.
https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F99b63013-8b6f-457e-aa9f-9ee72f134c88_1230x1216.jpeg